Usability Testing: Types, Methods, Tools, and Best Practices

Reading Time: 13 minutes

In today’s competitive digital landscape, creating products that are not only functional but also intuitive and user-friendly is vital. This is where usability testing comes into play. 

Whether you are developing a website, mobile app, or software platform, understanding how real users interact with your product can make the difference between success and failure.

In this design journal, we will explore what is usability testing, various usability testing methods, and real-world usability testing examples. We will also cover why usability testing matters and how it can help improve your product and business outcomes.

Understanding usability testing

At its core, usability testing is a structured process where real users interact with a product to evaluate how easy and effective it is to use. 

Unlike surveys or focus groups that rely on opinions, usability testing observes actual user behavior while performing specific tasks.

The goal is to identify usability issues, uncover pain points, and gather insights that help improve the product’s design and functionality. 

Usability testing focuses on measuring how well a product meets the needs and expectations of its users, ensuring it is intuitive, efficient, and satisfying to use.

Brief history and evolution

Usability testing has its roots in human-computer interaction research dating back to the 1980s. Early pioneers like Jakob Nielsen popularized the idea that testing with just five users can uncover the majority of usability problems, making it a cost-effective and iterative approach.

Over time, usability testing evolved from simple lab-based sessions to include a variety of usability testing methods such as remote testing, unmoderated sessions, and automated tools. 

Today, with the rise of digital products and diverse user bases, usability testing is more important than ever to ensure products are accessible and user-friendly.

Usability testing examples

McDonald’s: Improving mobile app usability before launch

Before launching their UK mobile app, McDonald’s conducted 20 usability tests covering the entire customer journey. 

This testing identified usability problems early, allowing the team to make necessary adjustments. The approach ensured the app met user expectations and helped McDonald’s compete more effectively in the mobile space.

Udemy: Understanding mobile learning behavior with remote testing

Udemy, a leading online learning platform, used fully remote, unmoderated usability testing to understand when and why users preferred their mobile app over the desktop site. 

Participants recorded videos showing their learning environment and tasks, providing rich contextual insights. This approach helped Udemy tailor their mobile experience to fit user habits and preferences better.

Why usability testing matters

Benefits for products and users

Usability testing is not just a checkbox in the development process- it is a critical step that delivers numerous benefits:

• Improves user satisfaction: By identifying and fixing pain points, usability testing creates a seamless and enjoyable experience that keeps users coming back.
  
• Uncovers hidden issues: Many usability problems are not obvious to designers or developers but become clear when observed with real users.
  
• Reduces development costs: Catching usability flaws early prevents expensive redesigns and bug fixes after launch.
  
• Increases conversion rates: For websites and apps, better usability often translates directly into higher signups, purchases, or other key actions.
  
• Supports accessibility: Testing helps ensure your product is usable by people with disabilities, expanding your audience and complying with legal standards.

Impact on business outcomes

The impact of usability testing extends beyond user experience to influence overall business success:

• Competitive advantage: Products that are easier and more pleasant to use stand out in crowded markets.
  
• Data-driven decisions: Usability testing provides concrete evidence to guide design and development priorities, reducing guesswork.
  
• Customer loyalty: Satisfied users are more likely to become repeat customers and brand advocates.
  
• Faster time to market: Efficient usability testing accelerates the development cycle by focusing efforts on what truly matters to users.

When to conduct usability testing

Stages in the product development lifecycle

Usability testing is a flexible and essential process that should be integrated throughout the entire product development lifecycle. Conducting usability tests at the right stages helps ensure your product remains user-centric and effective. 

Here are the key phases where usability testing is most valuable:

• Concept exploration: Early in the development process, usability testing can be conducted on paper sketches or wireframes to validate ideas and understand user needs. This helps define product requirements and identify potential usability challenges before investing heavily in design or development.

• Demonstration and validation: During this phase, prototypes are developed, and usability testing helps verify that the design meets user expectations and requirements. Testing at this stage can reveal whether the concept is viable and identify areas needing refinement.

• Detailed design and construction: As the product takes shape, usability testing ensures that integrated features work well together and that the user interface remains intuitive. This phase often involves iterative testing with more polished prototypes.

• Production and operation: After launch, usability testing continues to play a role in real-world environments, helping identify issues that arise with actual users and guiding product updates and improvements.

By embedding usability testing at these stages, teams can catch problems early, reduce costly redesigns, and continuously improve the user experience.

Signs you need usability testing

Knowing when to conduct usability testing can save time and resources. Here are common signs indicating that usability testing is necessary:

• Before a redesign: If your product is outdated or users report difficulties, usability testing the current version can highlight pain points and inform redesign priorities.

• Introducing new features: When adding new functionality, usability testing helps ensure these features are intuitive and meet user needs.

• Declining user engagement: Drops in user activity or conversions may indicate usability issues that testing can uncover.

• Conflicting stakeholder opinions: When teams disagree on design decisions, usability testing provides objective user data to guide choices.

• Preparing for launch: Testing before release helps catch usability problems that could negatively impact user adoption.

Types of usability testing

Usability testing comes in various forms, each suited to different goals and contexts. Understanding the main types helps you choose the right approach for your project.

Moderated vs. unmoderated testing

• Moderated testing: In this method, a facilitator guides participants through tasks, observing their behavior and asking follow-up questions in real time. This approach allows for deeper insights and immediate clarification but requires scheduling and more resources.
• Unmoderated testing: Participants complete tasks independently, usually via online platforms, without a facilitator present. This method is more scalable and cost-effective, enabling testing with larger groups, but offers less opportunity for probing user reactions.

Remote vs. in-person testing

• Remote testing: Conducted online, remote usability testing allows participants to use their own devices in their natural environments. This method increases geographic reach and convenience but may limit control over testing conditions.
• In-person testing: Held in a controlled environment such as a usability lab, in-person testing provides richer observational data and easier facilitation of complex tasks, but can be more costly and less flexible.

Explorative, assessment, and comparative testing

• Explorative testing: Conducted early in the design process to understand user needs, expectations, and potential usability issues with initial concepts or prototypes.
• Assessment testing: Focuses on evaluating the usability of a nearly finished product to identify remaining problems before launch.
• Comparative testing: Involves testing two or more design alternatives to determine which performs better from the user’s perspective.

Planning a usability test

Effective usability testing requires careful planning to ensure meaningful and actionable results.

Setting objectives and goals

Start by clearly defining what you want to learn from the usability test. Objectives might include:

• Identifying navigation issues
• Measuring task completion rates
• Understanding user satisfaction
• Testing a new feature’s intuitiveness

Clear goals help shape the test design and focus data collection.

Defining user tasks and scenarios

Create realistic tasks that reflect how users will interact with your product. Tasks should be:

• Specific and goal-oriented
• Representative of common user actions
• Free from leading instructions to avoid bias

Well-crafted scenarios enable you to observe genuine user behavior and uncover usability problems.

Recruiting participants

Select participants who closely match your target user personas. Consider factors such as:

• Demographics (age, gender, location)
• Experience level with similar products
• Technical proficiency

Recruiting the right users ensures your findings are relevant and reliable.

Running the usability test

Preparing test materials

Before you begin a usability test, preparing the right materials is crucial to ensure a smooth and effective session. This includes:

• Creating test scripts: Develop clear instructions and scenarios that guide participants through tasks without leading or confusing them. Test scripts should reflect real-world use cases to gather relevant data.

• Designing tasks: Define specific, goal-oriented tasks that users will perform during the test. These tasks should be realistic and cover key functionalities of the product.

• Setting up technology: Ensure all equipment, software, and usability testing tools are ready and functioning properly. This includes screen recording software, survey platforms, and communication tools for remote sessions.

• Preparing consent forms: Have documentation ready to inform participants about the test purpose, data usage, and their rights, securing informed consent.

Facilitating the session

During the usability test, the facilitator plays a vital role in guiding the session while minimizing bias:

• Introduce the session: Brief participants on the purpose of the test, emphasizing that the product, not the user, is being tested.

• Encourage think-aloud: Ask users to verbalize their thoughts as they complete tasks, providing valuable insight into their decision-making process.

• Avoid leading questions: Let users explore naturally, only intervening to clarify instructions or encourage elaboration without influencing behavior.

• Manage time: Keep the session on track, ensuring all planned tasks are completed within the allocated time.

Observing and recording user behavior

Capturing accurate data during the test is essential:

• Use screen and video recording: Record sessions to review user interactions, facial expressions, and verbal feedback later.

• Take notes: Document key observations, unexpected behaviors, and any difficulties users encounter.

• Collect metrics: Track quantitative data such as task completion rates, time on task, and error frequency to complement qualitative insights.

• Utilize usability testing tools: Tools like Maze, UserTesting, or Hotjar can automate data collection and provide rich analytics.

Analyzing usability test results

Collecting and organizing data

After testing, gather all data- video recordings, notes, survey responses, and metrics- and organize it systematically:

• Transcribe sessions: Convert verbal feedback into text to facilitate analysis.
• Tag and categorize: Group findings by themes such as navigation issues, content clarity, or technical errors.
• Filter data: Remove irrelevant or duplicate information to focus on actionable insights.

Identifying patterns and issues

Look for recurring problems or behaviors across multiple participants:

• Prioritize issues: Classify usability problems by severity and impact on user experience.
• Compare quantitative and qualitative data: Use metrics like task success rates alongside user comments to validate findings.
• Identify root causes: Understand why users struggled to inform targeted design improvements.

Reporting findings

Create a clear and concise report to communicate results effectively:

• Summarize key insights: Highlight major usability issues and positive findings.
• Use visuals: Incorporate screenshots, video clips, charts, and graphs for clarity.
• Recommend solutions: Provide actionable suggestions to address identified problems.
• Share with stakeholders: Ensure the report reaches designers, developers, and decision-makers to drive improvements.

Usability testing methods

Qualitative vs. quantitative methods

• Qualitative methods: Focus on understanding user behavior, motivations, and pain points through observations, interviews, and open-ended feedback. These methods provide rich, detailed insights but usually involve smaller sample sizes.

• Quantitative methods: Use numerical data such as task completion rates, time on task, and error counts to measure usability objectively. These methods often involve larger samples and statistical analysis.

Task-based testing

This task-based testing method involves assigning users specific tasks to complete while observing their interactions. It helps identify where users face difficulties and how efficiently they can achieve their goals.

A/B testing

A/B testing compares two or more design variants by exposing different user groups to each version and measuring their performance or preferences. It is useful for optimizing specific elements like button placement, color schemes, or content layouts.

Surveys and questionnaires

Post-test surveys gather user feedback on satisfaction, perceived ease of use, and overall experience. Standardized questionnaires like the System Usability Scale (SUS) provide benchmark scores to compare usability over time or across products.

Usability testing tools

Selecting the right usability testing tools can streamline your testing process and enhance data quality.

Here are some widely used options:

• Maze: Offers rapid prototyping and actionable insights with a free plan and paid tiers starting at $99/month. Ideal for both moderated and unmoderated testing.
• UserTesting: Suitable for large-scale research, providing video recordings and detailed analytics. Pricing ranges from $1,500 to $2,500 per seat.
• Hotjar: Combines heatmaps, session recordings, and surveys to analyze user behavior. Plans start at $32/month.
• Loop11: Supports A/B testing, prototype testing, and AI-powered insights. Loop11 pricing ranges from $199 to $599/month.
• Userfeel: Pay-as-you-go model, Userfeel is perfect for occasional tests, charging $60 per credit.
• Trymata (formerly TryMyUI): Trymata provides video recordings and collaborative annotations starting at $333/month.
• Useberry: Focuses on website and prototype testing with features like card sorting and tree testing. Useberry’s price starts at $79/month.
• UXCam: UXCam specializes in mobile app usability with session replays and heatmaps; pricing varies.

Criteria for Selecting Tools

When choosing usability testing tools, consider:

• Type of testing supported: Ensure the tool fits your preferred usability testing methods (moderated, unmoderated, remote, etc.).
• Ease of use: User-friendly interfaces reduce setup time and learning curves.
• Participant recruitment: Some tools offer built-in participant pools, simplifying recruitment.
• Data analysis features: Look for tools that provide both qualitative and quantitative insights, including video editing and AI-powered summaries.
• Budget: Consider pricing models- subscription vs. pay-as-you-go- and align with your testing frequency.
• Integration: Compatibility with other platforms, like analytics or project management tools, can enhance workflow.

Best practices for usability testing

• Define clear objectives: Before starting usability testing, clearly outline what you want to learn. Specific goals help you choose the right usability testing methods, design relevant tasks, and analyze results effectively. Without clear objectives, tests risk producing vague or unusable insights.

• Recruit a representative and diverse audience: Select participants who closely match your target users, including a range of demographics, abilities, and usage behaviors. Diversity ensures your findings reflect varied user experiences and helps uncover a broader spectrum of usability issues.

• Prepare realistic and actionable tasks: Design tasks that simulate real-world user goals without leading participants. Tasks should be clear, unbiased, and focused on key product functions. Well-crafted tasks encourage natural user behavior and provide meaningful data.

• Run a pilot test: Conduct a trial run with a small group or internal team to identify issues with test materials, instructions, or logistics. Piloting helps refine the process, ensuring smoother sessions and more reliable data during the actual usability testing.

• Obtain informed consent and set expectations: Clearly inform participants about the test’s purpose, how their data will be used, and their rights, including the option to withdraw at any time. Transparency builds trust and encourages honest feedback.

• Keep tests short and engaging: Limit the number of tasks to maintain participant focus and avoid fatigue. Short, engaging sessions yield more accurate and actionable insights.

• Use appropriate usability testing tools: Choose tools that fit your testing method and goals, whether moderated or unmoderated, remote or in-person. The right tools streamline data collection and analysis.

Common pitfalls and how to avoid them

• Testing with the wrong audience: Recruiting participants who do not represent your actual users leads to irrelevant or misleading results. Avoid this by carefully defining your target user profiles and recruiting accordingly.

• Vague or unfocused test scenarios: Ambiguous or unrealistic tasks confuse participants and produce unhelpful data. Ensure tasks are clear, specific, and aligned with real user goals to get meaningful insights.

• Treating usability testing as a one-time event: Conducting only a single usability test misses ongoing issues and evolving user needs. Adopt an iterative approach with multiple rounds of testing throughout the product lifecycle.

• Providing hints or leading participants: Guiding users during testing biases results and hides true usability problems. Facilitators should remain neutral, encouraging users to think aloud and explore naturally.

• Overlooking accessibility and mobile responsiveness: Ignoring accessibility and device diversity excludes many users and misses critical usability issues. Incorporate accessibility testing early and test across various devices and screen sizes.

• Poor planning and logistics: Failing to plan test logistics, such as scheduling, equipment setup, and participant recruitment, can derail usability testing. Detailed planning ensures smooth execution and reliable results.

• Ignoring data analysis and reporting: Collecting data without thorough analysis or clear reporting wastes valuable insights. Prioritize organizing, analyzing, and sharing findings to drive meaningful product improvements.

Conclusion

Usability testing is a critical practice for creating products that truly meet user needs. By identifying usability issues early and iterating based on real user feedback, teams can improve the overall user experience, increase satisfaction, and reduce costly redesigns. 

Employing the right usability testing methods and tools, along with recruiting representative users, ensures that insights are both relevant and actionable.

To get the most out of usability testing, it should be integrated throughout the product development lifecycle rather than treated as a one-time activity. 

Starting with clear objectives and continuing with regular testing cycles fosters a culture of continuous improvement. 

By prioritizing usability, businesses can build products that not only function well but also delight their users, driving long-term success.

We encourage you to explore additional resources and subscribe to our blog for more design insights.

Frequently asked questions

What are the biggest challenges in recruiting participants for usability testing?

Recruiting participants who accurately represent your target audience is often the biggest challenge. Niche markets or specialized user groups can be hard to reach. 

Additionally, budget constraints and limited time can restrict recruitment efforts. Using targeted outreach, participant recruitment platforms, and partnerships with relevant organizations can help overcome these hurdles.

How do you ensure usability testing covers accessibility needs?

To cover accessibility, include participants with disabilities and diverse abilities in your testing pool. Test your product with assistive technologies like screen readers and keyboard navigation. 

Follow established accessibility guidelines, such as WCAG, to design test scenarios. Collaborating with organizations that support users with disabilities can also improve recruitment and testing quality.

What steps can be taken to avoid bias during usability testing?

Avoid bias by using neutral, open-ended questions and refraining from leading or suggestive language. Facilitators should remain impartial and encourage participants to think aloud without interference. 

Unmoderated testing can reduce facilitator influence. Careful participant screening ensures a representative sample without excluding valid perspectives.

How do you handle usability testing for mobile devices and multiple platforms?

Testing across mobile devices and platforms requires access to various real devices or cloud-based device labs. Include participants who use different operating systems and screen sizes to capture diverse experiences. 

Design test tasks that reflect platform-specific interactions and constraints. Using usability testing tools that support mobile testing helps collect accurate data.

What can be done if users encounter unexpected problems during testing?

When unexpected problems arise, facilitators should observe without guiding users, encouraging them to describe their difficulties. Document these issues carefully, as they often reveal critical usability flaws. 

After testing, analyze these problems to identify root causes and prioritize fixes. Iterative testing helps confirm that solutions effectively address these issues.